【 Performance Comparison 】  
	
		
			
				
					
						Performance comparison 
					
				 
				
					
						Roots blower 
					
				 
				
					
						Multistage centrifugal air blower 
					
				 
				
					
						Single stage centrifugal blower 
					
				 
				
					
						Air suspension blower 
					
				 
				
					
						Imported maglev blower 
					
				 
				
					
						Esurging maglev blower 
					
				 
				
				 
			 
			
				
					
						Bearing 
					
				 
				
					
						Bearing 
					
				 
				
					
						Ball bearing 
					
				 
				
					
						Ball bearing 
					
				 
				
					
						Tilting-pad bearing 
					
				 
				
					
						Air foil bearing 
					
				 
				
					
						Imported magnetic bearing, mature technology, high stability 
					
				 
				
					
						First magnetic bearing developed independently in China, mature technology, high stability 
					
				 
				
					
						
					
				 
			 
			
				
					
						Technology source 
					
				 
				
					
						Made in China 
					
				 
				
					
						Made in China 
					
				 
				
					
						Import/domestic 
					
				 
				
					
						Republic of Korea 
					
				 
				
					
						Europe 
					
				 
				
					
						Tsinghua University 
					
				 
				
				 
			 
			
				
					
						Service life 
					
				 
				
					
						1-2 years 
					
				 
				
					
						2-3 years 
					
				 
				
					
						3-5 years 
					
				 
				
					
						3-5 years 
					
				 
				
					
						Semi-permanent 
					
				 
				
					
						Semi-permanent 
					
				 
				
				 
			 
			
				
					
						Mechanical loss 
					
				 
				
					
						2% energy consumption of bearing 
					
				 
				
					
						2% energy consumption of bearing 
					
				 
				
					
						Above 3% energy consumption of sliding friction 
					
				 
				
					
						Dry friction at low speed, high energy consumption 
					
				 
				
					
						Electromagnetic induction, low energy consumption of bearing 
					
				 
				
					
						Electromagnetic induction, low energy consumption of bearing 
					
				 
				
				 
			 
			
				
					
						Impeller 
					
				 
				
					
						Type 
					
				 
				
					
						Casting 2 or 3 blades 
					
				 
				
					
						Welding steel or casting aluminum 
					
				 
				
					
						Aluminum alloy three-dimensional flow impeller 
					
				 
				
					
						Aluminum alloy three-dimensional flow impeller 
					
				 
				
					
						Aluminum alloy three-dimensional flow impeller 
					
				 
				
					
						Aluminum alloy three-dimensional flow impeller 
					
				 
				
					
						
					
				 
			 
			
				
					
						Service life 
					
				 
				
					
						5-8 years 
					
				 
				
					
						10 years 
					
				 
				
					
						15 years 
					
				 
				
					
						20 years 
					
				 
				
					
						20 years 
					
				 
				
					
						20 years 
					
				 
				
				 
			 
			
				
					
						Aerodynamic efficiency 
					
				 
				
					
						Low 
					
				 
				
					
						Low 
					
				 
				
					
						Medium 
					
				 
				
					
						High 
					
				 
				
					
						High 
					
				 
				
					
						High 
					
				 
				
				 
			 
			
				
					
						High-speed motor 
					
				 
				
					
						Motor type 
					
				 
				
					
						Low-speed asynchronous motor 
					
				 
				
					
						Low-speed asynchronous motor 
					
				 
				
					
						Asynchronous ac motor 
					
				 
				
					
						High-speed permanent magnet motor 
					
				 
				
					
						Purchased high-speed permanent magnet motor 
					
				 
				
					
						High-speed permanent magnet motor independently developed 
					
				 
				
					
						
					
				 
			 
			
				
					
						Transmission type 
					
				 
				
					
						Belt or coupler 
					
				 
				
					
						Coupler 
					
				 
				
					
						Coupler 
					
				 
				
					
						Direct driving 
					
				 
				
					
						Direct driving 
					
				 
				
					
						Direct driving 
					
				 
				
				 
			 
			
				
					
						Motor efficiency 
					
				 
				
					
						86% 
					
				 
				
					
						87% 
					
				 
				
					
						94% 
					
				 
				
					
						95% 
					
				 
				
					
						97% 
					
				 
				
					
						Above 97% 
					
				 
				
				 
			 
			
				
					
						Speed control 
					
				 
				
					
						unavailable 
					
				 
				
					
						unavailable 
					
				 
				
					
						unavailable 
					
				 
				
					
						Precise control of speed 
					
				 
				
					
						Precise control of speed 
					
				 
				
					
						Precise control of speed 
					
				 
				
				 
			 
			
				
					
						Speed control method 
					
				 
				
					
						There is no speed control system. When motor power and rotation speed are fixed, the air volume is fixed 
					
				 
				
					
						No speed control system unless the variable frequency motor is replaced and the variable frequency converter is added 
					
				 
				
					
						Guide vane adjustment, mechanical loss 
					
				 
				
					
						Intelligent DC speed control system changes the speed of the shaft 
					
				 
				
					
						Intelligent DC speed control system changes the speed of the shaft 
					
				 
				
					
						Intelligent DC speed control system changes the speed of the shaft 
					
				 
				
				 
			 
			
				
				 
			 
			
				
				 
			 
			
				
					
						Working range 
					
				 
				
					
						Very small 
					
				 
				
					
						Very small, it can bebroadenedby adding a frequency converter 
					
				 
				
					
						Small range of adjustment of air flow and pressure 
					
				 
				
					
						Wide range of adjustment of air flow and pressure 
					
				 
				
					
						Wide range of adjustment of air flow and pressure 
					
				 
				
					
						Wide range of adjustment of air flow and pressure 
					
				 
				
				 
			 
			
				
					
						Installation 
					
				 
				
					
						Lifting 
					
				 
				
					
						Need 
					
				 
				
					
						Need 
					
				 
				
					
						Need 
					
				 
				
					
						No need 
					
				 
				
					
						No need 
					
				 
				
					
						No need 
					
				 
				
					
						
					
				 
			 
			
				
					
						Foundation 
					
				 
				
					
						Need 
					
				 
				
					
						Need 
					
				 
				
					
						Need 
					
				 
				
					
						No need 
					
				 
				
					
						No need 
					
				 
				
					
						No need 
					
				 
				
				 
			 
			
				
					
						Maintenance 
					
				 
				
					
						Lubricant 
					
				 
				
					
						Check every shift, add regularly, medium cost 
					
				 
				
					
						Check every shift, add regularly, medium cost 
					
				 
				
					
						Check every shift, add regularly, high cost 
					
				 
				
					
						No need 
					
				 
				
					
						No need 
					
				 
				
					
						No need 
					
				 
				
					
						
					
				 
			 
			
				
					
						Quick-wear part 
					
				 
				
					
						Bearing, gear 
					
				 
				
					
						Bearing, sealing 
					
				 
				
					
						Bearing, gear, lubricant pump 
					
				 
				
					
						Bearing, filter 
					
				 
				
					
						Air filter 
					
				 
				
					
						Air filter 
					
				 
				
				 
			 
			
				
					
						Cost 
					
				 
				
					
						Low 
					
				 
				
					
						Medium 
					
				 
				
					
						High 
					
				 
				
					
						High, no maintenance in China 
					
				 
				
					
						Low, poor service timeliness 
					
				 
				
					
						Low, good service timeliness 
					
				 
				
				 
			 
			
				
					
						Operation 
					
				 
				
					
						Operation cost 
					
				 
				
					
						Very high 
					
				 
				
					
						High 
					
				 
				
					
						Medium 
					
				 
				
					
						Low 
					
				 
				
					
						Very low 
					
				 
				
					
						Very low 
					
				 
				
					
						
					
				 
			 
			
				
					
						Investment cost 
					
				 
				
					
						Very low 
					
				 
				
					
						Medium 
					
				 
				
					
						High 
					
				 
				
					
						High 
					
				 
				
					
						High 
					
				 
				
					
						High 
					
				 
				
				 
			 
			
				
					
						Overall efficiency 
					
				 
				
					
						49% 
					
				 
				
					
						61% 
					
				 
				
					
						68% 
					
				 
				
					
						73% 
					
				 
				
					
						77% 
					
				 
				
					
						77% 
					
				 
				
				 
			 
			
				
					
						Overall price 
					
				 
				
					
						Low 
					
				 
				
					
						Medium 
					
				 
				
					
						High (imported blower) 
					
				 
				
					
						Medium 
					
				 
				
					
						Very high, 1.3~1.5 times of the domestic 
					
				 
				
					
						Medium 
					
				 
				
				 
			 
			
				
					
						After-sale maintenance 
					
				 
				
					
						Short cycle, low cost and high failure rate 
					
				 
				
					
						Short cycle and high cost 
					
				 
				
					
						Long maintenance period and high cost 
					
				 
				
					
						Long maintenance period and high cost 
					
				 
				
					
						Long maintenance period and high cost 
					
				 
				
					
						Timely maintenance, independent core components, short maintenance cycle and low cost 
					
				 
				
				 
			 
		
	
 
Performance comparison
Roots blower
Multistage centrifugal air blower
Single stage centrifugal blower
Air suspension blower
Imported maglev blower
Esurging maglev blower
Bearing
Bearing
Ball bearing
Ball bearing
Tilting-pad bearing
Air foil bearing
Imported magnetic bearing, mature technology, high stability
First magnetic bearing developed independently in China, mature technology, high stability
						
					
Technology source
Made in China
Made in China
Import/domestic
Republic of Korea
Europe
Tsinghua University
Service life
1-2 years
2-3 years
3-5 years
3-5 years
Semi-permanent
Semi-permanent
Mechanical loss
2% energy consumption of bearing
2% energy consumption of bearing
Above 3% energy consumption of sliding friction
Dry friction at low speed, high energy consumption
Electromagnetic induction, low energy consumption of bearing
Electromagnetic induction, low energy consumption of bearing
Impeller
Type
Casting 2 or 3 blades
Welding steel or casting aluminum
Aluminum alloy three-dimensional flow impeller
Aluminum alloy three-dimensional flow impeller
Aluminum alloy three-dimensional flow impeller
Aluminum alloy three-dimensional flow impeller
						
					
Service life
5-8 years
10 years
15 years
20 years
20 years
20 years
Aerodynamic efficiency
Low
Low
Medium
High
High
High
High-speed motor
Motor type
Low-speed asynchronous motor
Low-speed asynchronous motor
Asynchronous ac motor
High-speed permanent magnet motor
Purchased high-speed permanent magnet motor
High-speed permanent magnet motor independently developed
						
					
Transmission type
Belt or coupler
Coupler
Coupler
Direct driving
Direct driving
Direct driving
Motor efficiency
86%
87%
94%
95%
97%
Above 97%
Speed control
unavailable
unavailable
unavailable
Precise control of speed
Precise control of speed
Precise control of speed
Speed control method
There is no speed control system. When motor power and rotation speed are fixed, the air volume is fixed
No speed control system unless the variable frequency motor is replaced and the variable frequency converter is added
Guide vane adjustment, mechanical loss
Intelligent DC speed control system changes the speed of the shaft
Intelligent DC speed control system changes the speed of the shaft
Intelligent DC speed control system changes the speed of the shaft
Working range
Very small
Very small, it can bebroadenedby adding a frequency converter
Small range of adjustment of air flow and pressure
Wide range of adjustment of air flow and pressure
Wide range of adjustment of air flow and pressure
Wide range of adjustment of air flow and pressure
Installation
Lifting
Need
Need
Need
No need
No need
No need
						
					
Foundation
Need
Need
Need
No need
No need
No need
Maintenance
Lubricant
Check every shift, add regularly, medium cost
Check every shift, add regularly, medium cost
Check every shift, add regularly, high cost
No need
No need
No need
						
					
Quick-wear part
Bearing, gear
Bearing, sealing
Bearing, gear, lubricant pump
Bearing, filter
Air filter
Air filter
Cost
Low
Medium
High
High, no maintenance in China
Low, poor service timeliness
Low, good service timeliness
Operation
Operation cost
Very high
High
Medium
Low
Very low
Very low
						
					
Investment cost
Very low
Medium
High
High
High
High
Overall efficiency
49%
61%
68%
73%
77%
77%
Overall price
Low
Medium
High (imported blower)
Medium
Very high, 1.3~1.5 times of the domestic
Medium
After-sale maintenance
Short cycle, low cost and high failure rate
Short cycle and high cost
Long maintenance period and high cost
Long maintenance period and high cost
Long maintenance period and high cost
Timely maintenance, independent core components, short maintenance cycle and low cost
 
  
                
 
 









































































































































































 
  
                         
                        